|
REITs
Jan 2, 2018 11:55:45 GMT
Post by Deleted on Jan 2, 2018 11:55:45 GMT
Off topic for the forum but it stems from virtually all my property holdings being residential and on one platform (property partner). I am interested in diversifying into commercial property and reducing platform risk.
I am completely new to the idea of REITs but think it may be the direction to go for a small portion of my overall portfolio, I'd appreciate any overall thoughts on REITs and my current ideas of potential options below from those who are more familiar with the field.
British Land Company - Established Large REIT, potential Brexit risk but trading at discount
Tritax Big Box - Warehouse/Logistics facilities, with growth of online shopping
MedicX Fund (Potentially becoming a REIT) - Medical Facilities largely NHS
Target Healthcare - Considerable care home holdings, aging population
NewRiver Retail - Community/Convenience based retail which appear to be growing in popularity
|
|
jonno
Member of DD Central
nil satis nisi optimum
Posts: 2,806
Likes: 3,237
|
REITs
Jan 2, 2018 12:23:40 GMT
Post by jonno on Jan 2, 2018 12:23:40 GMT
Off topic for the forum but it stems from virtually all my property holdings being residential and on one platform (property partner). I am interested in diversifying into commercial property and reducing platform risk. I am completely new to the idea of REITs but think it may be the direction to go for a small portion of my overall portfolio, I'd appreciate any overall thoughts on REITs and my potential options below from those who are more familiar with the field. British Land Company - Established Large REIT, potential Brexit risk but trading at discount Tritax Big Box - Warehouse/Logistics facilities, with growth of online shopping MedicX Fund (Potentially becoming a REIT) - Medical Facilities largely NHS Target Healthcare - Considerable care home holdings, aging population NewRiver Retail - Community/Convenience based retail which appear to be growing in popularity I've been involved in REITs for some time now in Medicx and NewRiver from your list above, and more recently in LXI and AEW Long Lease. These have proved worthy, if not wildly exciting income providers and are reasonably predictable investments. The other side of the coin of them having to pay 90% of their earnings in dividends is that they have little or no capital left to grow and consequently other than offering more shares (dilution) they need to borrow, so turning the spotlight on our old friend LTV. So look carefully at their leverage levels as this could be an issue in a significant down-turn. Of course as with all IT's they can be trading at a premium or discount to their underlying Asset Value.
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Jan 2, 2018 12:24:42 GMT
Hi Jester, I started looking at REITs about 3 years ago. The critical issues for me were
1) Have to be based in the UK but in a tax dodging regime, so anywhere in the Channel Isles will do. REIT margins are generally so poor (and of course due to the nature of the tax of REITS it makes sense) 2) I wanted the REIT to have a clear strategy that has worked in the past and will work in the future with the right sort of tactical people on board to achieve that strategy 3) I wanted the spread to be small, so there are enough shares in the market to make it work and to allow stops to occur when I want them to 2) I intially looked at true UK REITs and concluded that the market was just too fashionable (especially in terms of Chinese investors) 3) Then came Brexit I decided to focus outside the UK. The big REITs are generally in Germany and linked states (so Netherlands, Denmark etc) 4) Of these only two were easily UK tradable and had a strategy that made any sense based and any historical track record with a future (for instance there is a REIT that aims to own property in Berlin and has failed to maximise that strategy since 2012, literally they don't seem to know what to do, but are still taking their salary etc)
The only one that seems to be placed well is SRE, it operates a REGUS type operation but offering medium sized offices and workshops around the secondary and major cities in Germany. From my experience in Germany such a strategy makes complete sense and I'm happily up on the deal. Of course the Euro following wind is a nice thing to have.
Of your five, they may be good but I spent time on their web pages and was not impressed
British Land Company - going no where, some bad investments and no real direction
Tritax Big Box - .more I read the website the more it looks unfocused
MedicX Fund not a REIT
Target Healthcare - Possible interest, but share price not going anywhere, my own view is carehomes will be disrupted in the next 5 years, so avoid at the moment and buy a proper care home company share
NewRiver Retail owns things that no one wants, pub, shopping malls etc all in decline
|
|
|
REITs
Jan 2, 2018 13:08:58 GMT
Post by Deleted on Jan 2, 2018 13:08:58 GMT
Care homes;
McCarthy & Stone are interesting, obviously they have been writing off a lot of debt as part of the recovery from being in private equity (evil squid). Right now they have gearing sorted at around 0% according to stockopedia.
However buy to let legislation just kicked them in the knackers
"Dec 21 (Reuters) - Britain's biggest builder of homes for retirees McCarthy & Stone MCS.L said on Thursday it had requested an exemption from the government's proposal to set ground rents to zero, but would work on strategies to maintain profits if that effort failed. The company's shares fell as much as 14 percent, hitting its lowest in over three months. By 0948 GMT, the stock was more than 9 percent lower. The British government proposed in July that builders be banned from selling leasehold homes in England and ground rents on flats could be cut to zero, responding to public criticism about price hikes facing leaseholders. "This potential change to the structure of ground rents will be immediately reflected in the cost of land secured for development by McCarthy & Stone with a margin-neutral impact for shareholders in the medium term," McCarthy & Stone said. The company said it had made a "strong case" for the exemption of retirement housing providers from such action, and said it would request further details on possible exemptions. Dec 21 (Reuters) - Britain's biggest builder of homes for retirees McCarthy & Stone MCS.L said on Thursday it had requested an exemption from the government's proposal to set ground rents to zero, but would work on strategies to maintain profits if that effort failed. The company's shares fell as much as 14 percent, hitting its lowest in over three months. By 0948 GMT, the stock was more than 9 percent lower. The British government proposed in July that builders be banned from selling leasehold homes in England and ground rents on flats could be cut to zero, responding to public criticism about price hikes facing leaseholders. "This potential change to the structure of ground rents will be immediately reflected in the cost of land secured for development by McCarthy & Stone with a margin-neutral impact for shareholders in the medium term," McCarthy & Stone said. The company said it had made a "strong case" for the exemption of retirement housing providers from such action, and said it would request further details on possible exemptions. "
|
|
|
REITs
Jan 2, 2018 17:31:07 GMT
Post by Deleted on Jan 2, 2018 17:31:07 GMT
jonno, I suppose worthy but not wildly exciting is exactly what I'm after. A regular solid return to balance a more aggressive equity portfolio but in an alternate area of investment! @bobo thanks for the detailed and considered reply, you have rather shot all my REIT ideas to pieces, so not sure where to go from here. As for your advice to buy care home shares and then sharing an article ripping McCarthy and Stone apart, well that just left me even more bewildered
|
|
|
REITs
Jan 2, 2018 17:32:03 GMT
via mobile
Post by beeje13 on Jan 2, 2018 17:32:03 GMT
jester have you considered (or already have) an infrastructure fund? It may not be a direct property investment but it's got the commercial slant you are looking for. Utilities, transport (toll roads) etc.. E.G. there is First State global listed infrastructure. It's an OEIC. 10 years annualised performance for the B Acc class is 9.59%, which is 2.1% above the index annualised. I myself want to get into REIT'S but investing through IT's doesn't suit me currently.
|
|
|
REITs
Jan 2, 2018 18:01:38 GMT
Post by Deleted on Jan 2, 2018 18:01:38 GMT
You might also like TRIG for infrastructure
Hope I've not put you off, just opinons
|
|
macq
Member of DD Central
Posts: 1,934
Likes: 1,199
|
REITs
Jan 2, 2018 18:37:37 GMT
Post by macq on Jan 2, 2018 18:37:37 GMT
jonno , I suppose worthy but not wildly exciting is exactly what I'm after. A regular solid return to balance a more aggressive equity portfolio but in an alternate area of investment! @bobo thanks for the detailed and considered reply, you have rather shot all my REIT ideas to pieces, so not sure where to go from here. As for your advice to buy care home shares and then sharing an article ripping McCarthy and Stone apart, well that just left me even more bewildered in a not wildly exciting vain have you looked at IT's such as Picton property income & F&C commercial property or TR property? For infrastructure IT's they have been trading at very high premiums for 3i or just high for the likes of HICL or International public partnership
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Jan 2, 2018 21:36:47 GMT
beeje13 to be perfectly honest this is completely new to me, my only self-select equity holdings are Vanguard trackers albeit a geographically ambitious portfolio. So having said that I hadn't remotely considered an Infrastructure fund, I appreciate the suggestion and will look into it. What is your thinking behind saying that " I myself want to get into REIT'S but investing through IT's doesn't suit me currently." @bobo , you definitely haven't put me off, all advice and opinion is welcome and I'll take it on board in my decisions. I'm not writing off REITs as I like the concept for my portfolio but I'm completely open to alternates I don't yet no about. Having said that I'm using iWEB platform so at £5 a trade I'm deciding what is the least I can commit to per fund, £500 perhaps, 1% trade cost !??! TRIG again looks interesting, my only renewable investment is through AbundanceP2P macq thanks for the recommendations, so many options out there, it's a mine field. As a novice can I ask why you put these IT's forward over the suggested REITs? Also what do you mean by "high premiums for 3i" ?
|
|
|
REITs
Jan 2, 2018 21:47:28 GMT
via mobile
Post by beeje13 on Jan 2, 2018 21:47:28 GMT
beeje13 to be perfectly honest this is completely new to me, my only self-select equity holdings are Vanguard trackers albeit a geographically ambitious portfolio. So having said that I hadn't remotely considered an Infrastructure fund, I appreciate the suggestion and will look into it. What is your thinking behind saying that " I myself want to get into REIT'S but investing through IT's doesn't suit me currently." @bobo , you definitely haven't put me off, all advice and opinion is welcome and I'll take it on board in my decisions. I'm not writing off REITs as I like the concept for my portfolio but I'm completely open to alternates I don't yet no about. Having said that I'm using iWEB platform so at £5 a trade I'm deciding what is the least I can commit to per fund, £500 perhaps, 1% trade cost !??! TRIG again looks interesting, my only renewable investment is through AbundanceP2P macq thanks for the recommendations, so many options out there, it's a mine field. As a novice can I ask why you put these IT's forward over the suggested REITs? Also what do you mean by "high premiums for 3i" ? There are some great Investment Trusts that I would like to invest with. But I regular save every month in sums of £25 per fund (to benefit from pound cost averaging) - I don't have any initial charges/fees when doing this with OEICS/ Unit Trusts. But I would have to pay 0.5% stamp duty and £1.50 dealing fee per transaction with IT's, which is quite significant on a £25 investment and would amount to a lot over time. However my broker has capped charges on holding IT's so at the point when it becomes sensible (I only have a relatively small portfolio) I will liquidate my OEICS/UT's and buy IT's to keep charges low.
|
|
macq
Member of DD Central
Posts: 1,934
Likes: 1,199
|
REITs
Jan 2, 2018 22:12:08 GMT
Post by macq on Jan 2, 2018 22:12:08 GMT
beeje13 to be perfectly honest this is completely new to me, my only self-select equity holdings are Vanguard trackers albeit a geographically ambitious portfolio. So having said that I hadn't remotely considered an Infrastructure fund, I appreciate the suggestion and will look into it. What is your thinking behind saying that " I myself want to get into REIT'S but investing through IT's doesn't suit me currently." @bobo , you definitely haven't put me off, all advice and opinion is welcome and I'll take it on board in my decisions. I'm not writing off REITs as I like the concept for my portfolio but I'm completely open to alternates I don't yet no about. Having said that I'm using iWEB platform so at £5 a trade I'm deciding what is the least I can commit to per fund, £500 perhaps, 1% trade cost !??! TRIG again looks interesting, my only renewable investment is through AbundanceP2P macq thanks for the recommendations, so many options out there, it's a mine field. As a novice can I ask why you put these IT's forward over the suggested REITs? Also what do you mean by "high premiums for 3i" ? There are some great Investment Trusts that I would like to invest with. But I regular save every month in sums of £25 per fund (to benefit from pound cost averaging) - I don't have any initial charges/fees when doing this with OEICS/ Unit Trusts. But I would have to pay 0.5% stamp duty and £1.50 dealing fee per transaction with IT's, which is quite significant on a £25 investment and would amount to a lot over time. However my broker has capped charges on holding IT's so at the point when it becomes sensible (I only have a relatively small portfolio) I will liquidate my OEICS/UT's and buy IT's to keep charges low. with regards regular saving in IT's have you ever looked at share plans run direct by the trust themselves which may work out cheaper then you think.I know Baillie Gifford,Witan,F&C run their own & Aberdeen and others may still do which i think only charge a yearly plan fee and stamp duty and if there is a dealing charge some let you invest quarterly
|
|
macq
Member of DD Central
Posts: 1,934
Likes: 1,199
|
REITs
Jan 2, 2018 22:30:10 GMT
Post by macq on Jan 2, 2018 22:30:10 GMT
beeje13 to be perfectly honest this is completely new to me, my only self-select equity holdings are Vanguard trackers albeit a geographically ambitious portfolio. So having said that I hadn't remotely considered an Infrastructure fund, I appreciate the suggestion and will look into it. What is your thinking behind saying that " I myself want to get into REIT'S but investing through IT's doesn't suit me currently." @bobo , you definitely haven't put me off, all advice and opinion is welcome and I'll take it on board in my decisions. I'm not writing off REITs as I like the concept for my portfolio but I'm completely open to alternates I don't yet no about. Having said that I'm using iWEB platform so at £5 a trade I'm deciding what is the least I can commit to per fund, £500 perhaps, 1% trade cost !??! TRIG again looks interesting, my only renewable investment is through AbundanceP2P macq thanks for the recommendations, so many options out there, it's a mine field. As a novice can I ask why you put these IT's forward over the suggested REITs? Also what do you mean by "high premiums for 3i" ? mentioned the property IT's as more traditional offerings over your student or big box choices(but that may not make them better for you) 2 own property and the TR trust is in builders etc and i think has some interests in Europe.The high premium on 3i is due to how popular this trust and others in infrastructure have become partly due to their yield.Not sure its 100% correct but in general open ended funds in infrastructure i believe will buy in to companies where the IT's may own the project i.e toll roads & bridges etc. Others will explain better but IT's will trade on a premium or discount most of the time but some do control it to try and keep it at par -its a bit like the Ablrate SM where the better loans may get asked a slight premium.But thats not to say that trusts on a discount are bad or indeed may be a good buy especially if the discount narrows.You can even have a trust such as Impax Enviromental Markets be up about 150% over 5 years and about 20% for the year but on an average 11% discount for the last year
|
|
|
REITs
Jan 3, 2018 6:50:54 GMT
via mobile
macq likes this
Post by beeje13 on Jan 3, 2018 6:50:54 GMT
macq I have seen those, but that would meanbyet another investment account for me to handle! and I would have to give up my ISA allowance for the year for just one trust - I don't like putting all my eggs in one basket.
|
|
|
Post by peerlessperil on Jan 3, 2018 9:46:10 GMT
REITs have a valid place in a broad investment portfolio, especially for those looking to generate a dependable income stream from a diverse range of investments. If you are looking to get rich quickly then gamble elsewhere, but if you wish to harness the power of compounding dividend income then REITs can be very useful. The main point of note for retail investors is that REITs are obliged to pay 90% of their income out as dividends to retain certain tax advantages. Most of the major listed property companies converted into REITs back in 2007 - hence Land Securities, British Land, Hammerson, Segro (back then it would have been Slough Estates & Brixton Estates) and others all became REITs. Segro is the market darling of the moment owing to its large exposure to logistics warehouses of the type favoured by online retailers. REITs are shares first, property investments second. In the short term they can perform in a manner that is more correlated to the stock market than property markets. The primary risk is rising interest rates, and REITs have a three-fold exposure. Firstly they are big users of debt financing, so bond markets matter to their future profitability. Secondly, commercial property valuations are underpinned by a presumed yield. As yields rise, values drop. Yes, rents can rise to offset rising yields, but usually not enough. Thirdly, they are income investments, and as rates rise so the attraction of property vs cash diminishes as investors find leaving money in the bank less punitive in real terms. You can think of a REIT as a loose basket of secured corporate bonds with some development upside - each lease has fixed-income characteristics and if a tenant defaults the landlord can re-let or sell the property. The advantage overlooked by many is that institutional long leases in the UK are often linked to inflation, so there is a degree of inflation hedging available that is currently so expensive to source in the index-linked gilt market (where inflation will need to exceed 2% just to avoid a negative return). Why a REIT over direct investment in a commercial property? - Liquidity - you can always sell the shares, even if you may not like the price
- Diversification - much less concentrated exposure to tenant default
- Gearing - REITs can leverage more cheaply than you can, and commercial mortgages are cumbersome
- Convenience - you don't have to manage the tenants
- Development project upside (varies by REIT)
The majors: Land Secs - the largest and a bit of a slow-moving supertanker, 62% London by value..... Brit Land - lots of office exposure, especially financial district, plus some retail. Not a bad contrarian bet if the current Brexit fears prove excessive. Hammerson - large shopping centres with some European exposure (& currently acquiring rival shopping reit INTU) Segro - logistics warehouses, lots of Heathrow exposure, some european, had a very good run Great Portland - more London exposure There are some good smaller sector specialist REITs that are worth a good look - Derwent, Shaftesbury, Workspace to name a few. Then there are the funds like F&C Commercial and portfolios run by the major fund management houses - plenty of comment elsewhere on these.
|
|
|
Post by longjohn on Jan 3, 2018 12:21:39 GMT
Take a look at Trustnet.com They monitor pretty much everything and and have a good analysis of all types of collective funds. This will take you to property investment trusts - www.trustnet.com/fund/price-performance/t/investment-trusts?tab=fundOverview&assetclass=PROP&pageSize=125There are 77 available ranging from generic to specialist. Pay attention to the FE Risk Score, lower is better. It's a good starting point for more detailed research. I specialise and have investments in - Primary Health Properties = Owns doctors surgeries and medical centres. Rents are paid by NHS/Government so pretty safe. 4.5% Yield. Town Centre Securities = Owns Leeds shopping centre and several others plus lots of car parks. Not much to go wrong and the motorist always pays so no lack of income. Haven't cut their dividend in 57 years which is a record they want to keep. Yield 4% Regional REIT = Does not invest within M25. Just had a rights issue to get fresh money for investing. 5% discount and 7.5% Yield. REIT's usually pay a general dividend plus a property income distribution (PID). The PID is taxed at source but within an ISA the tax is automatically claimed back 6-8 weeks later. Do plenty of research and choose something that captures your interest and puts a smile on your face. There's nothing like walking into my local doctors surgery/shopping centre/car park and knowing I own a bit of it. J
|
|