|
Post by Deleted on Apr 18, 2017 21:32:13 GMT
I am a big believer in diversification when it comes to investment but I have no doubt there are many areas I could improve on this front and much I could learn about. I'd be very interested in any thoughts on areas I could move into beyond my current positions or viewpoints on my current portfolio.
I'm currently fairly evening divided 1/3, 1/3, 1/3 in cash(fsca protected bank accounts and premium bonds), p2p (perhaps a bit too committed in this area), stocks and shares.
-Within p2p I lend through RS, Z, LW, LB, BM, LfSS, MT, FS and Abundance. If anything I feel a bit property heavy and tend to avoid SME!
-My stocks and shares are all currently held with Moneyfarm as I have little knowledge in this area and spend my available time on p2p, so have been leaving the decisions to them
One area which frequently gets mentioned which I'm not involved with is BuyToLet, would people recommend the likes of Property Partner and Property Moose as an avenue into this world?
|
|
pom
Member of DD Central
Posts: 1,922
Likes: 1,244
|
Post by pom on Apr 19, 2017 6:52:52 GMT
1/3 cash sounds a lot to me but it all depends how much you need. I started worrying my cash was getting low and then looked at it again and worked out how long it would last (I think most people work on the basis of a few months worth, maybe up to a year....mine is umm... more) and carried on investing it.. P2P I expect we're probably all a bit property heavy and wary of SMEs....the "obvious" place for some alternative assets is ABL, and COL still has non-property stuff too. S&S I'm very hands off...but plenty others on the forum are often recommending FundSmith and other stuff. I thought about trying some others on the side, but decided to just stick with what I have not least as my pension is also S&S so by the time I add up all my S&S I'm looking at over half. BTL I still like it, but it does take quite a while to get a diversified portfolio, which you'll need as some of the properties performance has been absolutely shocking (but still better than buying a whole house yourself and having it empty in my book). But it's mostly dividend income, so if you're not totally focussed on highest rates possible it can still make sense.
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Apr 19, 2017 7:29:43 GMT
Premium Bonds! What exactly do you expect to earn out of them?
My FSA reckons you should have enough cash to survive a year without a job. I'm not sure if this is right, but that is his view.
I'd keep P2P at between 5 and 10% of by capital (ignoring houses) but closer to the 5%.
|
|
alanp
Member of DD Central
Posts: 168
Likes: 72
|
Post by alanp on Apr 19, 2017 9:11:16 GMT
I'd start thinking about this from the point of view of your objective or objectives - What are you trying to achieve with your savings / investments and over what timescale?
Approx 6 months easy access cash available in case of dire emergencies such as losing your job as you don't want to be selling S&S in a rush to free up some cash as the job loss may well occur at the same time as a an economic / market downturn - particularly if you have a mortgage / rent / household bills to pay (although a working partner can offset some of this if not in same industry or even worse with same employer.
S&S best for longer term objectives, at least 5 years plus, ideally 10+ - so the likes of retirement etc. assuming you are still a way off that.
House purchase? Dependants? and the like also need to be considered.
Personally, like bobo, I am down at the 5-10% level of non-pension / non-residence assets in P2P and wouldn't want to be higher.
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Apr 19, 2017 11:17:15 GMT
alanp @bobo 5% in p2p ?? Really wow that is low, would hardly make it worth my time bothering. I understand it is an untried and non stress tested arena compared to S&S but I try to minimise the impact of any unknowns by holding a comparatively low amount circa 2/3% on any one platform. I'd be interested in moving into the BTL market but again through a platform such as Property Partner/Moose in place of some P2P @bobo as for premium bonds, I simply figured if I need to retain a proportion as cash/emergency fund which will earn next to nothing compared to my other investments anyway, then I may as well have a bit of a punt with it where the capital is at least protected! alanp I'm really thinking about growing my invesment portfolio between now and retirement with thoughts towards doing that at an early age (or at least wind down) from the income and then in turn providing a lump for my children as long as my work pension is still around to keep me going in my later years! So long term growth I suppose is the answer, I'm not risk averse in terms of maximising growth but as I've said am keen to diversify widely to avoid any disasters if possible. pom cheers for the input, we sound of similar(ish) thoughts, my 1/3 in cash isn't so much a few months survival cash and more just a need to keep some under FSCA protection but I'm willing to look at this is further opportunities present themselves
|
|
pom
Member of DD Central
Posts: 1,922
Likes: 1,244
|
Post by pom on Apr 19, 2017 11:25:56 GMT
alanp @bobo 5% in p2p ?? Really wow that is low, would hardly make it worth my time bothering. I understand it is an untried and non stress tested arena compared to S&S but I try to minimise the impact of any unknowns by holding a comparatively low amount circa 2/3% on any one platform. I rather suspect they have rather bigger overall pots! I don't think I'd bother for 5% either - or if I did I'd have a very different strategy with fewer platforms. Think I'm at about 22% at the moment, last time I looked. Edit - ok 21% p2p, 6% BTL, 13% cash (too much still), 60% S&S (incl pensions - more than I'd like but the damn things keep growing!).... so given I'm not intending to be making massive pension contributions much longer I guess I'll have to keep expanding P2P and BTL.. (in fact what AM I doing? Been far too distracted from financial planning recently...)
|
|
bg
Member of DD Central
Posts: 1,368
Likes: 1,929
|
Post by bg on Apr 19, 2017 12:16:36 GMT
For what its worth I am currently 37% in equities, 27% in P2P and 33% in buy to lets. This includes borrowings against some of my properties to invest more in P2P.
3% of my portfolio is currently in cash.
I only think you should hold cash for four reasons. 1) as money to live on, 2) in case a good opportunity arises, 3) in case you are going to buy something (like a property, car or holiday) or 4) you think other asset prices are over valued and are expecting a correction.
If you have capital you don't need for a while it's best to have it invested and earning a return. Over my life the people that have become rich are those that have invested (be that in property or the stock market or a business) over a long period of time and those that have remained (relatively) poor are those that haven't invested and have kept their savings in cash, eroding value over time (usually because they say they don't understand it or don't want to take any risk).
FSCA protection - I really think that's a bit of a red herring. If you have a well diversified portfolio (I appreciate I have an aggressive portfolio but that is my decision as right now I think equities have a lot of upside and bonds are rich) and can afford to stay invested over a period of time then you will make a return.
The worlds wealth is not going to drop to zero overnight. Be invested in productive assets. Cash is unproductive, it loses value over time - a good quality, well run business will generate wealth and earn you a decent return.
|
|
alanp
Member of DD Central
Posts: 168
Likes: 72
|
Post by alanp on Apr 19, 2017 13:15:33 GMT
alanp @bobo 5% in p2p ?? Really wow that is low, would hardly make it worth my time bothering. I understand it is an untried and non stress tested arena compared to S&S but I try to minimise the impact of any unknowns by holding a comparatively low amount circa 2/3% on any one platform. I'd be interested in moving into the BTL market but again through a platform such as Property Partner/Moose in place of some P2P @bobo as for premium bonds, I simply figured if I need to retain a proportion as cash/emergency fund which will earn next to nothing compared to my other investments anyway, then I may as well have a bit of a punt with it where the capital is at least protected! alanp I'm really thinking about growing my invesment portfolio between now and retirement with thoughts towards doing that at an early age (or at least wind down) from the income and then in turn providing a lump for my children as long as my work pension is still around to keep me going in my later years! So long term growth I suppose is the answer, I'm not risk averse in terms of maximising growth but as I've said am keen to diversify widely to avoid any disasters if possible. pom cheers for the input, we sound of similar(ish) thoughts, my 1/3 in cash isn't so much a few months survival cash and more just a need to keep some under FSCA protection but I'm willing to look at this is further opportunities present themselves Overall pot is quite small but only spread across 3 main platforms (+1 I am running down), most with automatic renewals or longer term loans so just manages itself really. Withdraw or re-invest interest is about it most of the time. If I had 40-50 platforms to manage I would go nuts, don't see how you can do it, but good luck to you. Currently have 17% of cash in P2P as I am mainly focused on S&S via pensions.
|
|
alanp
Member of DD Central
Posts: 168
Likes: 72
|
Post by alanp on Apr 19, 2017 13:19:27 GMT
For what its worth I am currently 37% in equities, 27% in P2P and 33% in buy to lets. This includes borrowings against some of my properties to invest more in P2P. 3% of my portfolio is currently in cash. I only think you should hold cash for four reasons. 1) as money to live on, 2) in case a good opportunity arises, 3) in case you are going to buy something (like a property, car or holiday) or 4) you think other asset prices are over valued and are expecting a correction. If you have capital you don't need for a while it's best to have it invested and earning a return. Over my life the people that have become rich are those that have invested (be that in property or the stock market or a business) over a long period of time and those that have remained (relatively) poor are those that haven't invested and have kept their savings in cash, eroding value over time (usually because they say they don't understand it or don't want to take any risk). FSCA protection - I really think that's a bit of a red herring. If you have a well diversified portfolio (I appreciate I have an aggressive portfolio but that is my decision as right now I think equities have a lot of upside and bonds are rich) and can afford to stay invested over a period of time then you will make a return. The worlds wealth is not going to drop to zero overnight. Be invested in productive assets. Cash is unproductive, it loses value over time - a good quality, well run business will generate wealth and earn you a decent return. It's all relative though isn't it. 3% of how much is the question. For someone who has say £10k available for investment, a mortgage & family and is the only earner keeping 3% in cash would not be sensible as the car might break next week, or the boiler or something. Even at a £100k it doesn't make sense to me, but at a £1m then it makes a lot more sense (assuming that covers your main outgoings for a few months)
|
|
bg
Member of DD Central
Posts: 1,368
Likes: 1,929
|
Post by bg on Apr 19, 2017 13:52:35 GMT
For what its worth I am currently 37% in equities, 27% in P2P and 33% in buy to lets. This includes borrowings against some of my properties to invest more in P2P. 3% of my portfolio is currently in cash. I only think you should hold cash for four reasons. 1) as money to live on, 2) in case a good opportunity arises, 3) in case you are going to buy something (like a property, car or holiday) or 4) you think other asset prices are over valued and are expecting a correction. If you have capital you don't need for a while it's best to have it invested and earning a return. Over my life the people that have become rich are those that have invested (be that in property or the stock market or a business) over a long period of time and those that have remained (relatively) poor are those that haven't invested and have kept their savings in cash, eroding value over time (usually because they say they don't understand it or don't want to take any risk). FSCA protection - I really think that's a bit of a red herring. If you have a well diversified portfolio (I appreciate I have an aggressive portfolio but that is my decision as right now I think equities have a lot of upside and bonds are rich) and can afford to stay invested over a period of time then you will make a return. The worlds wealth is not going to drop to zero overnight. Be invested in productive assets. Cash is unproductive, it loses value over time - a good quality, well run business will generate wealth and earn you a decent return. It's all relative though isn't it. 3% of how much is the question. For someone who has say £10k available for investment, a mortgage & family and is the only earner keeping 3% in cash would not be sensible as the car might break next week, or the boiler or something. Even at a £100k it doesn't make sense to me, but at a £1m then it makes a lot more sense (assuming that covers your main outgoings for a few months) Yeah of course. That's why I say you should have enough money to live on (and that includes your family) for as many months/years as makes you feel comfortable. There's no point in investing if it causes you to be constantly stressing about paying the mortgage.
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Apr 19, 2017 14:29:34 GMT
alanp @bobo 5% in p2p ?? Really wow that is low, would hardly make it worth my time bothering. I understand it is an untried and non stress tested arena compared to S&S but I try to minimise the impact of any unknowns by holding a comparatively low amount circa 2/3% on any one platform. I'd be interested in moving into the BTL market but again through a platform such as Property Partner/Moose in place of some P2P @bobo as for premium bonds, I simply figured if I need to retain a proportion as cash/emergency fund which will earn next to nothing compared to my other investments anyway, then I may as well have a bit of a punt with it where the capital is at least protected! alanp I'm really thinking about growing my invesment portfolio between now and retirement with thoughts towards doing that at an early age (or at least wind down) from the income and then in turn providing a lump for my children as long as my work pension is still around to keep me going in my later years! So long term growth I suppose is the answer, I'm not risk averse in terms of maximising growth but as I've said am keen to diversify widely to avoid any disasters if possible. pom cheers for the input, we sound of similar(ish) thoughts, my 1/3 in cash isn't so much a few months survival cash and more just a need to keep some under FSCA protection but I'm willing to look at this is further opportunities present themselves I don't make much more than 10% interest (after defaults) on P2P which frankly is border-line worth it (there are so many better deals about), but it fills a hole in the income part of my tax, virtually everything else is capital or inside ISA/SIPP protection. So really just getting in the numbers and taking advantage of the tax freedom and of course adding to my charitable giving. 2 to 3% per portal would drive me nuts. I have portals that are dying, and growing portals. (so 4 growers and 3 cashing out) , I hope to get back to 5, but the loans I have with the dying portals are still good rates so, I just have to wait. Out of my total in P2P I try to keep below 2% in any one loan but may drift up to 3%. I also aim to keep straight property below 40%, which is tough.
|
|
mike
Member of DD Central
Posts: 187
Likes: 121
|
Post by mike on Apr 19, 2017 16:06:26 GMT
alanp @bobo 5% in p2p ?? Really wow that is low, would hardly make it worth my time bothering. I understand it is an untried and non stress tested arena compared to S&S but I try to minimise the impact of any unknowns by holding a comparatively low amount circa 2/3% on any one platform. I'd be interested in moving into the BTL market but again through a platform such as Property Partner/Moose in place of some P2P @bobo as for premium bonds, I simply figured if I need to retain a proportion as cash/emergency fund which will earn next to nothing compared to my other investments anyway, then I may as well have a bit of a punt with it where the capital is at least protected! alanp I'm really thinking about growing my invesment portfolio between now and retirement with thoughts towards doing that at an early age (or at least wind down) from the income and then in turn providing a lump for my children as long as my work pension is still around to keep me going in my later years! So long term growth I suppose is the answer, I'm not risk averse in terms of maximising growth but as I've said am keen to diversify widely to avoid any disasters if possible. pom cheers for the input, we sound of similar(ish) thoughts, my 1/3 in cash isn't so much a few months survival cash and more just a need to keep some under FSCA protection but I'm willing to look at this is further opportunities present themselves I don't make much more than 10% interest (after defaults) on P2P which frankly is border-line worth it (there are so many better deals about), but it fills a hole in the income part of my tax, virtually everything else is capital or inside ISA/SIPP protection. So really just getting in the numbers and taking advantage of the tax freedom and of course adding to my charitable giving. 2 to 3% per portal would drive me nuts. I have portals that are dying, and growing portals. (so 4 growers and 3 cashing out) , I hope to get back to 5, but the loans I have with the dying portals are still good rates so, I just have to wait. Out of my total in P2P I try to keep below 2% in any one loan but may drift up to 3%. I also aim to keep straight property below 40%, which is tough. I'de be interested to hear about some of the "better deals about" that you have looked at.
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Apr 19, 2017 16:46:19 GMT
look at low standard deviation (low deviation ensures that timing is less of an issue) funds using a tool like trustnet. Someone like Fundsmith is the cherry on the cake, but to get diversity there are many funds giving year on year better than P2P, and you get to take the tax as capital gain rather than income, finally park it in a portal that does not rip you off with excess management fees. Really the days of 1% management fees to manage a secure website are long gone (unless you are FC). Diversification, still required so you need a mix of economic areas and industry sectors, but let the standard deviation be your guide.
Risks; tinkering with your assets! Limit yourself to only look at them every 3 months or so. A bit like gardening and very different from P2P which requires a lot of time, Funds require a whole day's research every 3 months or so.
|
|
|
Post by catalist on Apr 19, 2017 17:45:39 GMT
You say you try avoiding SME lending. Can you please elaborate on this?
To me, of course subject to platform scoring systems, segment etc., SME lending, especially secured one, seems the safest p2p asset class by far.
|
|
gibmike
Member of DD Central
What is a cynic? A man who knows the price of everything and the value of nothing.
Posts: 256
Likes: 160
|
Post by gibmike on Apr 19, 2017 18:04:33 GMT
@bobo makes a lot of sense when he talks about S&S and I 100% agree with him.
I don't tend to read may investment books as they are always yesterdays chip wrappers but many of the people I agree with are longer term investors who preach the same rules, invest long term and review once a year. If a correction comes about, buy your funds/ stocks at a lower rate and add rather than sell (never ever sell during a correction).
My breakdown is as follows:
15% P2P and Factoring 33% S&S 28% My property (mortgage almost gone) 27% Others (including a few years cash to live on)
My plan is to "live off" P2P and Factoring within the next 2-3 years and allow S&S / others to appreciate to point whereby I can switch to the 4% rule and quit.
Make hay whilst the sun shines as they say, generating 12% returns (before losses) which is compounding weekly, my issue is balance between portals at the moment (I am using mainly AC, FS and LI).
|
|