littleoldlady
Member of DD Central
Running down all platforms due to age
Posts: 3,045
Likes: 1,862
|
Post by littleoldlady on Nov 16, 2020 18:10:17 GMT
Why doesn't the total of "capital outstanding" equal "Invested money"?
|
|
Greenwood2
Member of DD Central
Posts: 4,396
Likes: 2,789
|
Post by Greenwood2 on Nov 17, 2020 14:00:32 GMT
Why doesn't the total of "capital outstanding" equal "Invested money"? The difference is probably mainly uninvested money, in the queue to lend (which is quite slow at present). Goto Summary and click on manage next to each product to see how much is waiting to lend, either matching, repayments or new money.
|
|
aju
Member of DD Central
Posts: 3,500
Likes: 924
|
Post by aju on Nov 17, 2020 14:49:34 GMT
Why doesn't the total of "capital outstanding" equal "Invested money"? The difference is probably mainly uninvested money, in the queue to lend (which is quite slow at present). Goto Summary and click on manage next to each product to see how much is waiting to lend, either matching, repayments or new money. In my case I also need to check holding as relend is off and I move returned funds/interest etc to bank to get interest elsewhere. (I've rearranged the screens slightly so I can see all items on one screen of my PC to make things easier to see all at once) There are other scenarios too in that during any given weekday (Sometime on weekends too) there are a number of processes moving funds around too such as defaults/collections, returned capital, returned interest etc etc. Most of the batch runs take place overnight to keep things invisible as much as possible but increasingly many times the Zopa batch processes can get held up and even might stall and have to be restarted when staff come in in the mornings. (Things are getting much slower on both zopa screens and the backend processes) I seem to remember that Zopa explained all this some time ago but I can't find the most recent explanation. There are also scenarios when they have found code errors and corrected them too.
|
|
littleoldlady
Member of DD Central
Running down all platforms due to age
Posts: 3,045
Likes: 1,862
|
Post by littleoldlady on Nov 17, 2020 18:29:22 GMT
Why doesn't the total of "capital outstanding" equal "Invested money"? The difference is probably mainly uninvested money, in the queue to lend (which is quite slow at present). Goto Summary and click on manage next to each product to see how much is waiting to lend, either matching, repayments or new money. If you are right you are saying that a figure described as "Invested Money" includes uninvested money. In any case my Capital Outstanding total (from the portfolio download) is 43% more (not less) than the Invested Money on the site, and my uninvested money is almost zero.
|
|
Greenwood2
Member of DD Central
Posts: 4,396
Likes: 2,789
|
Post by Greenwood2 on Nov 17, 2020 20:23:00 GMT
The difference is probably mainly uninvested money, in the queue to lend (which is quite slow at present). Goto Summary and click on manage next to each product to see how much is waiting to lend, either matching, repayments or new money. If you are right you are saying that a figure described as "Invested Money" includes uninvested money. In any case my Capital Outstanding total (from the portfolio download) is 43% more (not less) than the Invested Money on the site, and my uninvested money is almost zero. If you are going from the downloads maybe you have not included defaults in the capital outstanding, ie, a chunk of it has defaulted? Defaults are taken into account in the dashboard figures.
|
|
Greenwood2
Member of DD Central
Posts: 4,396
Likes: 2,789
|
Post by Greenwood2 on Nov 18, 2020 8:28:10 GMT
Looking back at old spreadsheets, I used to compare the Overall Balance on the site to my Overall Balance calculated from:
Total Paid In - Total Taken Out + 'Earnings to Date'
Zopa now give a figure for all of these, (if you accept their figures). I used to keep track of money in and out and calculate earnings to date from:
Interest earned - Defaults + Bonuses
Now there are also Debt Sales and Recoveries to take into account. I'm not sure if Recoveries are accounted for in the defaults, I think they probably are, but I don't think Debt Sales are allocated to specific loans.
To get to the 'Invested Money' you then have to account for un-lent funds, as discussed above.
I haven't done this routinely for a long time and I'm sure there are lots of other ways of reconciling the figures.
|
|
littleoldlady
Member of DD Central
Running down all platforms due to age
Posts: 3,045
Likes: 1,862
|
Post by littleoldlady on Nov 18, 2020 9:14:53 GMT
If you are right you are saying that a figure described as "Invested Money" includes uninvested money. In any case my Capital Outstanding total (from the portfolio download) is 43% more (not less) than the Invested Money on the site, and my uninvested money is almost zero. If you are going from the downloads maybe you have not included defaults in the capital outstanding, ie, a chunk of it has defaulted? Defaults are taken into account in the dashboard figures. If defaults are not included in the dashboard figure (which seems logical) then this accounts for about half of the discrepancy. There is also a chunk with status "Withdrawn". What are they?
|
|
Greenwood2
Member of DD Central
Posts: 4,396
Likes: 2,789
|
Post by Greenwood2 on Nov 18, 2020 9:49:06 GMT
If you are going from the downloads maybe you have not included defaults in the capital outstanding, ie, a chunk of it has defaulted? Defaults are taken into account in the dashboard figures. If defaults are not included in the dashboard figure (which seems logical) then this accounts for about half of the discrepancy. There is also a chunk with status "Withdrawn". What are they? Withdrawn just means the borrower has the money. I don't know enough about how and when funds are written off but anything Closed with funds outstanding, default, deceased, possibly collection and settled which I think include loans that have been sold in the debt sales, may not be in the Dashboard figure. There are also deferred repayments, I expect they are still in the Dashboard figures. aju is definitely the Zopa expert! He may be along to explain all. As in my previous post I attacked the account balance check from a different angle.
|
|
littleoldlady
Member of DD Central
Running down all platforms due to age
Posts: 3,045
Likes: 1,862
|
Post by littleoldlady on Nov 18, 2020 10:26:27 GMT
If defaults are not included in the dashboard figure (which seems logical) then this accounts for about half of the discrepancy. There is also a chunk with status "Withdrawn". What are they? Withdrawn just means the borrower has the money. I don't know enough about how and when funds are written off but anything Closed with funds outstanding, default, deceased, possibly collection and settled which I think include loans that have been sold in the debt sales, may not be in the Dashboard figure. There are also deferred repayments, I expect they are still in the Dashboard figures. aju is definitely the Zopa expert! He may be along to explain all. As in my previous post I attacked the account balance check from a different angle. Thanks. I think the answer is to ignore loans that are defaulted or settled. I suppose these are included in the download for completeness but IMO they just confuse things and it would be better if they were downloaded separately if required.
|
|
aju
Member of DD Central
Posts: 3,500
Likes: 924
|
Post by aju on Nov 18, 2020 10:49:29 GMT
If defaults are not included in the dashboard figure (which seems logical) then this accounts for about half of the discrepancy. There is also a chunk with status "Withdrawn". What are they? Withdrawn just means the borrower has the money. I don't know enough about how and when funds are written off but anything Closed with funds outstanding, default, deceased, possibly collection and settled which I think include loans that have been sold in the debt sales, may not be in the Dashboard figure. There are also deferred repayments, I expect they are still in the Dashboard figures. aju is definitely the Zopa expert! He may be along to explain all.As in my previous post I attacked the account balance check from a different angle. (Blue text marker) An interesting concept - me being an expert in Zopa. littleoldlady , If you are looking for descriptions of the relevant fields then the Zopa Glossary, available on the loanbook page may be of interest. www.zopa.com/invest/loanbook-glossaryIt's available from both Loanbook pages and is titled "loan book glossary" secure2.zopa.com/lender/loan_book/standard/current for Invest and secure2.zopa.com/lender/loan_book/isa/current for ISA You have to be logged in for all these links to work and if you use them to get there much quicker you may find that logging out will not clear the cookies correctly. (I use direct links quite a bit to get me where I want to be and have found that once logged out just looping the top left and right links when logged out does eventually clear them all and I can then login without being immediately logged back out again (Zopa seems to have lost track of the cookies they use probably due to making changes without understanding the flow diagrams they probably don;t have!). Very boring I know but using direct links will allow much quicker traversing around an increasingly slow web page system I find.) Hope this helps you understand the loanbook fields better and helps you to marry up the numbers - there are quite a lot to work with I'm afraid. The main issue's I have found is that things are changing daily, even hourly, and it takes quite some effort to keep on top of things without specialised tool (interlinked spreadsheets in my case). Sadly I have tools coming out of my earholes for want of a better term but if I noticed something like you seem to have then I might be tempted to just go to Zopa and get them to investigate it. In my case - myself and mrs aju have 4 accounts 2 each - I have not found that much of a discrepancy of late and definitely nothing as large as you may have suggested across our 4 products I have found small discrepancies over somedays when the systems get out of sync due to overloads I feel but as I say nothing that looks that far out. In fact I can even see from the dashboard when to consider a removal of funds as the lineup to my data can see when they are more than a few pence different to my last checks. (I use this method as its not always a give that overnights will run the same time or even at all. - they mostly do not run over the weekends ) I have spreadsheet totalisers for both Zopa and RS and it's very clear to me that the time of day and sometimes even the Day of the week can mean that things get out of sync quite a bit in both systems. This is just the nature of these routine batch processes etc. In reality if you can prove that Zopa has an error in their systems and can identify where to them it can be quite a lucrative excercise if they deem that they have made a boo boo - I have stated elsewhere that we made more in compo payments than interest a couple of years or so ago. My experience working with Zopa they have always been very receptive in the past and users helping them to get their systems working better has never been a big issue. Sometimes one has to push past the front end triage and get someone who understands the workings at these levels to take notice but they usually help rather than hinder. In my view they are very open to users input most of the time, one of the better players in my view. Anyway I hope the glossary will help you understand things better, apologies if you already have that info and its still unclear do not hesitate to ask - I am not a Zopa expert at the level that zopa people are though far from it just a user who was in the software business a good few years back and now uses spreadsheets to monitor my accounts to the n'th degree - sad old git that I am..
|
|
aju
Member of DD Central
Posts: 3,500
Likes: 924
|
Post by aju on Nov 18, 2020 11:00:59 GMT
Withdrawn just means the borrower has the money. I don't know enough about how and when funds are written off but anything Closed with funds outstanding, default, deceased, possibly collection and settled which I think include loans that have been sold in the debt sales, may not be in the Dashboard figure. There are also deferred repayments, I expect they are still in the Dashboard figures. aju is definitely the Zopa expert! He may be along to explain all. As in my previous post I attacked the account balance check from a different angle. Thanks. I think the answer is to ignore loans that are defaulted or settled. I suppose these are included in the download for completeness but IMO they just confuse things and it would be better if they were downloaded separately if required. No I disagree that the defaults and settled are not useful in the tables. You can ignore them if you are using an excel (or other) spreadsheet. If you are just using the loanbook pages then you are missing a lot of data, I assume you are downloading the loanbook. Edit: Just re-read the above and realised you are downloading the loanbook. I'm not sure how Greenwood2 is approaching the checks but I would add that none of my checks involve the loanbook to get the true value of what is in our accounts daily. I also don't use Zopa's monthly email info either. I just use a combination of the statements data and the Zopa Summary info and I just use the relevant totals to get the full sum. At the end of each month usually in the 1st few days of the next month I download the Statements and the loanbooks and collate them both into monthly snapshot values that at that point. I check the data in my snapshots against the data on the day and it generally lines up on the day - bearing in mind that loading all the statements (100's of thousands of records since we started) can take sometime now on excel 2007 so I usually update my daytoday table first just before I drag the csv's.
|
|
littleoldlady
Member of DD Central
Running down all platforms due to age
Posts: 3,045
Likes: 1,862
|
Post by littleoldlady on Nov 18, 2020 12:17:07 GMT
Thanks. This is a relatives's account that I am managing under a LPA. He doesn't have enough in there (lowish 4 figures) to justify me spending the amount of time on it that you do. He is running down his investment and I just wanted to look at his loan book to get a rough idea of the future time line of repayments. Subtracting defaults and settled gets me close enough to the dashboard figure. So unless anyone knows of a way of speeding up his exit from the platform, (I don't think even dying would work), then we can close this thread.
|
|
aju
Member of DD Central
Posts: 3,500
Likes: 924
|
Post by aju on Nov 18, 2020 18:10:30 GMT
Thanks. This is a relatives's account that I am managing under a LPA. He doesn't have enough in there (lowish 4 figures) to justify me spending the amount of time on it that you do. He is running down his investment and I just wanted to look at his loan book to get a rough idea of the future time line of repayments. Subtracting defaults and settled gets me close enough to the dashboard figure. So unless anyone knows of a way of speeding up his exit from the platform, (I don't think even dying would work), then we can close this thread. So you could sell some loans if they are not that affected by checking what it might cost and even if it was possible. We sold as much as we could till we were left with the unsalable. Anything marked as withdrawn has the potential to be sold. YOu can use the system to check what the impact of a sale if at all possible might be. There are a couple of issues cost wise in that everything will have a 1% selling fee and then on top of that there is the MRA (Market Rate adjustment) whilst it added quite a bit to the cost (we paid 5% in some cases) it can still be a good move as teh defaults going forward may be an issue covid-19 wise. The things to look out for is easily readable in the statements system in that looking at statements over the last few months to see whether the interest received is being overwhelmed by the default costs month on month. In our case we made some big sales a while back and last year and also turned off relend. This state does give quite a marked increase in defaults effect on interest returns. All that said defaults can actually be recovered naturally or by debt sales although these are harder to associate with given defaults usually. Just as a quick check of my ISA core sale options I got this Loan sale estimate The MRA on this is approx 5.6% on top of the 1.0% so not a great deal, we clearly have a lot of loans, mostly < £10 that are affected by current situation as Zopa says ... I haven't bothered with the link in that text as its not very helpful or worse is out of date and not working. You can have a play with the loan sale pages as you can back out if you want.
|
|
littleoldlady
Member of DD Central
Running down all platforms due to age
Posts: 3,045
Likes: 1,862
|
Post by littleoldlady on Nov 18, 2020 18:40:09 GMT
Thanks aju I should have said that I sold everything that would sell, about 80% or so of the loan book. Took quite a hit but less than interest earned so he has not lost out on those loans, it remains to be seen how much of the rump he will get back. 95% is non-performing one way or another
|
|
aju
Member of DD Central
Posts: 3,500
Likes: 924
|
Post by aju on Nov 18, 2020 19:11:38 GMT
Thanks aju I should have said that I sold everything that would sell, about 80% or so of the loan book. Took quite a hit but less than interest earned so he has not lost out on those loans, it remains to be seen how much of the rump he will get back. 95% is non-performing one way or another No probs, its a similar situation for us now in Zopa and even less in RS. You should be getting quite a bit of a defaults hit if not already but definitely soon unless you are still re-investing which tends to cushion the default effects, i.e eating away at returns already made. Even then for us it was cleqar that the defaults were not going to be covered by the interest if sooner then later than we realised before the covid thing hit to make it much worse. That said having checked a lot of the Covid affected stuff for us the majority are still paying some funds and many are paying what they owe monthly too so its not all bad. time will tell though For us we made some considerable returns whilst the going was good having been in Zopa since nearly the beginning so we are cushioned quite a bit but still have enough invested and un-releasable to hurt quite a bit if things get worse.
|
|