criston
Member of DD Central
Posts: 1,204
Likes: 628
|
Post by criston on Aug 12, 2021 14:58:23 GMT
Left with odds & ends, but having checked if I had any loans I could sell, there was one.
£25.24 with market rate adjustment of £9.66 & £0.25 fee.
Took it anyway, but is this now the norm ?
|
|
aju
Member of DD Central
Posts: 3,500
Likes: 924
|
Post by aju on Aug 12, 2021 15:06:27 GMT
Left with odds & ends, but having checked if I had any loans I could sell, there was one. £25.24 with market rate adjustment of £9.66 & £0.25 fee. Took it anyway, but is this now the norm ? Hmm! I thought it was bad a year ago when we sold a lot more with MRA's of 3 to 4%. What was the original interest rate of the loan and what product was it in?. Edit: Just checked our stats files for back in 2020 (Apr-Aug selling was very slow at the time) where we were selling loans off and it seemed the higher the number of loans made the better the MRA. For me: best was 4.18% and worst was 6.25% For Mrs Aju: 3.45% 4.26% Its not very good guide as the my worst was 5 loans (£30.44) in Core and Mrsw Aju was 768 loans (£4991) again in core. In your case with only a single loan it may well be that you got it with a very low IR initially but the current situation has much higher rates. Hence the increase for the new lender is necessary. Still seems quite high though.
|
|
trium
Member of DD Central
Posts: 384
Likes: 304
|
Post by trium on Aug 13, 2021 10:46:55 GMT
The size of MRAs will depend on the difference between the nominal rate on the loan and the rate you could get on a similar loan in today's market. Since it is essentially up-front interest, the longer a loan has left to run the bigger the MRA will be.
I have not sold any loans but I have recycled repayments. There was a time, early in the pandemic, when virtually everything I picked up was a second hand loan with significant MRA adjustments attached. Since new lending restarted I've had hardly any MRA payments so I'm surprised if sellers are being charged at all at the moment (I'll check recent acquisitions when I get home).
In any case, this example does seem very high and I'd ask for an explanation if I were you.
|
|
criston
Member of DD Central
Posts: 1,204
Likes: 628
|
Post by criston on Aug 13, 2021 10:51:20 GMT
The size of MRAs will depend on the difference between the nominal rate on the loan and the rate you could get on a similar loan in today's market. Since it is essentially up-front interest, the longer a loan has left to run the bigger the MRA will be. I have not sold any loans but I have recycled repayments. There was a time, early in the pandemic, when virtually everything I picked up was a second hand loan with significant MRA adjustments attached. Since new lending restarted I've had hardly any MRA payments so I'm surprised if sellers are being charged at all at the moment (I'll check recent acquisitions when I get home). In any case, this example does seem very high and I'd ask for an explanation if I were you. Yesterday I asked Zopa to justify the 38%.
|
|
aju
Member of DD Central
Posts: 3,500
Likes: 924
|
Post by aju on Aug 13, 2021 14:13:39 GMT
The size of MRAs will depend on the difference between the nominal rate on the loan and the rate you could get on a similar loan in today's market. Since it is essentially up-front interest, the longer a loan has left to run the bigger the MRA will be. I have not sold any loans but I have recycled repayments. There was a time, early in the pandemic, when virtually everything I picked up was a second hand loan with significant MRA adjustments attached. Since new lending restarted I've had hardly any MRA payments so I'm surprised if sellers are being charged at all at the moment ( I'll check recent acquisitions when I get home). In any case, this example does seem very high and I'd ask for an explanation if I were you. I'm curious where/how you might see MRA payments coming in. Prior to the Feb change of system one was able to see the MRA payments going out when selling but i'm not sure there was anything in statements data for incoming MRA but i've checked in my statements and its not possible to see anything in the the new statements that i can see. (I haven't checked all new statements back to 2015 for all our accounts though. Edit: I've had a play now with Mrs aju's newest ISA Loans now that we both have turned on re-lend since the last week of July. It looks to me like she has benefited from some MRA of about 50p across 5 new loans. The largest MRA amount was 28p against a £5 Plus loan she got today (13/8) for a cost to her of £4.72 with an interest rate of 15.21% (The loanbook fields I used were Transaction Price, Transaction Date and Amount invested. The interest outstanding today was £2.04 and its a 5 year car loan) I checked out the info in the earlier loan books and not sure that I can backtrack to see how much we might have received over the years. Sadly pre feb changes version of loanbook had these fields and a full set in the alltime loanbook but they do not look quite so useful with quite a few loans having been removed from the new loanbooks its hard to backtrack accurately I think. I'm happy to be corrected on the fields i used to check the MRA amounts though.
|
|
trium
Member of DD Central
Posts: 384
Likes: 304
|
Post by trium on Aug 14, 2021 10:34:25 GMT
aju As I think you've realised the information is derived from the loan book, not from statements. My current loan book shows that I had a spate of RR loans in early April 2020, nearly all of which had MRA payments attached effectively discounting those loans by an average 3.1%. Like most others I then stopped lending for the most part - a few loans in late July/early August attracted around 4% "Normal" lending didn't resume until mid-February 2021. There have been fewer RR loans since then and generally lower MRAs. I picked up a few small ones in July but so far in August only 1p. Of course, the new practice of weeding old stuff out of the loan book means that I've likely lost some data, but it seems clear that rates in general went up early in the crisis and have since softened. Edit: I'm not entirely sure but it looks like old data is kept in the loan book for 12 months after the loan ends.
|
|
aju
Member of DD Central
Posts: 3,500
Likes: 924
|
Post by aju on Aug 14, 2021 13:28:08 GMT
aju As I think you've realised the information is derived from the loan book, not from statements. My current loan book shows that I had a spate of RR loans in early April 2020, nearly all of which had MRA payments attached effectively discounting those loans by an average 3.1%. Like most others I then stopped lending for the most part - a few loans in late July/early August attracted around 4% "Normal" lending didn't resume until mid-February 2021. There have been fewer RR loans since then and generally lower MRAs. I picked up a few small ones in July but so far in August only 1p. Of course, the new practice of weeding old stuff out of the loan book means that I've likely lost some data, but it seems clear that rates in general went up early in the crisis and have since softened. Edit: I'm not entirely sure but it looks like old data is kept in the loan book for 12 months after the loan ends. Yes trium you are right I had not realised this was available in the new loanbook having tried to understand it when they introduced the fields last year I think - they kept adding new fields that trashed my loaders until they completely removed older fields and dropped a number of loans that were in their eyes no longer useful for the new reduced loanbook. On the the loans being removed after 12 months that's an interesting thought. When the system changed over I spent a considerable amount of time with Zopa trying to line up the old and the new with a view to still maintaining the full loanbook. I gave up comparing as they are still in quite a state of change and still not getting it right in the statements area at least. The loanbook does not appear to have changed since the updates but I've not been monitoring it very closely until now that we are re lending again. They provided me with a translation for all my loans of a fashion (it took Zopa 4 attempts to actually get some useful data that was not in error) even so I still had to do quite a lot of data connections in excel to eventually get a full and accurate connection table of old and new loan/borrower ID's). Whilst i was doing all this it soon became very clear that during the the conversion good loans had seemingly gone missing completely from the new loanbook even though they had not seemed to complete in the old ones prior to the Feb "big bang" uplift. It turned out that Zopa had some issues with the initial rebuild attempt hence the delay of a week too. In the end I was able to get them to accept and admit there was an issue with some loans having been removed completely from the new data as a result of the need to remove all the completed loans up to a given date etc (Their words not mine). I had 6 loans that were completely wiped away 1 was settled and 3 had in fact completed during the delay period and hence were not transferred and were not showing as complete in the older alltime loanbook data either. I managed to create a number of issues from my old statements detail and see that some were nowhere near complete but Zopa loanbook said they were finished and so removed. eventually I had to create a list of issues for our 4 accounts of the lost loans so they could advise what had actually happened. From a large number of email discussions, sadly not in emails, i'm pretty sure they are not removing loans now it was just an opportunity they had taken to do as part of the changeover in February without taking note of 7 day slip due to the initial failed upgrade attempt. I am curious where you may have got the notion of 12 months before removals of completed loans yourself was it a comment from Zopa or is it just a theory you have. Mind you I did find that in my first dealings after the rebuild in Feb there were a number of Zopa customer service people just trying to fob off issues etc so much so that I now deal with a much higher person than normal customer service - I nearly got as far as Natasha Weir at one point. I've stopped comparing now and i'm not sure that loans are now going missing at all but I haven't checked since i was told the lost good loans were a mistake on Zopa's part ( I was able to get legitimate answers for all the loans that affected our 4 accounts). My personal feeling is there was great merit in having all loans data from day one and i'm sure that Zopa has this still as financial requirement but hey its gone now from the perspective of the pre big bang visibles we now have .
|
|
trium
Member of DD Central
Posts: 384
Likes: 304
|
Post by trium on Aug 14, 2021 14:01:40 GMT
Well I don't want to hijack criston 's thread but the observation/speculation about retiring loans from the loan book is based on the fact that if I sort the book in order of "loan end date" most closed loans are less than 12 months past that date. If I look again three months later I see the same situation, so those that were 9 to 12 months "dead" have gone rather than now appearing 12 to 15 months past it. But I stress I'm just guessing and I have no particular insight.
|
|
aju
Member of DD Central
Posts: 3,500
Likes: 924
|
Post by aju on Aug 14, 2021 14:32:27 GMT
Well I don't want to hijack criston 's thread but the observation/speculation about retiring loans from the loan book is based on the fact that if I sort the book in order of "loan end date" most closed loans are less than 12 months past that date. If I look again three months later I see the same situation, so those that were 9 to 12 months "dead" have gone rather than now appearing 12 to 15 months past it. But I stress I'm just guessing and I have no particular insight. I agree about hijacking the thread but just from our perspective on loans being lost since the feb update. Not sure if it means much but I've just checked Mrs Aju's ISA loans, she has way more than i do, and after processing out the new ones she has picked up since she started re lending this year. She has sold a lot of loans since Feb but checking the newest loanbook after the feb changes against the old loans in yesterdays loanbook she has the same number of loans so unless they are waiting for a 12 month cycle from whence they changed over then the loans are not being removed as far as i can tell so far. It's harder now to see when a loan actually finishes since they removed the detailed statements - I am taking a loanbook copy as close to 23:59 on the last day of the month for each loanbook. At least i can say what month a loan completed by comparing aginst the previous and adding a Completed month field in. If we stay lending then I may find knowing month when loans finish might be of use. I would add that since we sold many loans over the last year or so then the close date of a loan will not be great indicator for us I think (I'm still trying to understand what you are measuring exactly) I will check with Zopa too if they have plans to reduce the loans in the current loanbook when they are completed as i can't find email where i thought they said it was a one off removal and my offline notes are a bit of a mess having been working with them for so long on so many issues. Sorry criston for hijacking the thread.
|
|
aju
Member of DD Central
Posts: 3,500
Likes: 924
|
Post by aju on Aug 17, 2021 10:45:57 GMT
trium I'm not sure if this helps but i have had a response back from my contact in Zopa that I have been working with since they changed the loanbooks. Hope this conclusive statement clarifies their position on the loanbooks. Of course if you really have lost loans in the book which can happen then that is clearly an error that requires further investigation. Whilst at this time it does seem Zopa has no future plans to change the loanbook moving forward I would expect that as time passes and more large investors come along then there may be more issues of large loanbooks further down the line. Hope that answers the items we were discussing above regarding loans being dropped out of the loanbooks when completed. I wonder also by now if criston has also had an answer to their issue with what looks like an excessively high MRA payment.
|
|
criston
Member of DD Central
Posts: 1,204
Likes: 628
|
Post by criston on Aug 17, 2021 10:58:47 GMT
No answer yet, but if it is a standard type patronising answer, then I will ask for calculations.
Now that would be interesting !
|
|
aju
Member of DD Central
Posts: 3,500
Likes: 924
|
Post by aju on Aug 17, 2021 11:23:16 GMT
No answer yet, but if it is a standard type patronising answer, then I will ask for calculations. Now that would be interesting ! Yeah i'm curious although our selling days are over for a while and we have been reinvesting since last week in July. I kept much better records of our sales etc when the full statements details were available, prior to the Feb changes, but these days it's not that easy when one is selling 100's of loans. The new statements just detail the overview of sales and its much harder to get the loan breakdowns. For one loan though I cannot see that Zopa would not be able to supply the info you want, after all the Zopa (P2P) CEO has stated recently via my contact that we can have access to any data info we require if we ask for it.
|
|
criston
Member of DD Central
Posts: 1,204
Likes: 628
|
Post by criston on Aug 25, 2021 13:12:34 GMT
The loan had been in arrears.
Zopa refuses to give me their calculations.
The original interest rate was 2.39% AER
The remaining term of the 5 year loan was 17 months to 19/1/23.
So 38% divided by 17 months = 27% pa added to 2.39% = 29% rounded.
So the new buyer should have received 29% if my figures are correct.
|
|
|
Post by kvd on Aug 25, 2021 22:54:13 GMT
Yeah i'm curious although our selling days are over for a while and we have been reinvesting since last week in July. I kept much better records of our sales etc when the full statements details were available, prior to the Feb changes, but these days it's not that easy when one is selling 100's of loans. The new statements just detail the overview of sales and its much harder to get the loan breakdowns. For one loan though I cannot see that Zopa would not be able to supply the info you want, after all the Zopa (P2P) CEO has stated recently via my contact that we can have access to any data info we require if we ask for it. Did you actually speak to the Ceo or did you speak to the managwr
|
|
aju
Member of DD Central
Posts: 3,500
Likes: 924
|
Post by aju on Aug 25, 2021 23:14:23 GMT
Did you actually speak to the Ceo or did you speak to the managwr No I was advised by a manager I was challenging about the loss of certain data who discussed it with the CEO (Natasha Weir) and relayed her comment that Zopa can and should provide any data a user wishes if they have it. (It was really my beef about having low level statement data, this old data I have enables us to see where they are making a right pigs ear of some of the recent changes. In essence if you ask for data, and they can supply it, then they would. I am less concerned these days in that it's no longer a major part of our portfolio so I'm a little more sanguine on their removal of useful information that have had access to in the past. That said they have helped with quite a bit since the recent changes right down to providing tables of old borrower ID to new format ones that enable both myself and Mrs Aju to then compare all our loans in the new version against the old versions. There were quite a few mistakes made in the uplift including loans going missing and we managed to sort a lot of issues out with that translation. (It took about 5 passes back and forth before the info was in a form that one could make the matches. but they spent the time providing it none the less.) Their new end of year PDF generator seems to have a number of issues too especially now that Zopa does not feel the need to guide us in taxable items other than actual interest. Quite a number of non taxable items are being crossed with taxables for some of us making it impossible to isolate some items to declare. They are still working on that one and maybe for a while I think! ...
|
|