|
Post by zakaz on Apr 12, 2015 20:13:37 GMT
I am selling my appartment since it is high time to sell it as the market in Estonia is ripe enough. After sale I will have around 150 000 EUR on my hands. I could reinvest into the properties of another country wher renting Yields are high ATM(Chisinau, Riga) but that would end up being around 7-9% Net yield before tax, which is not impressive. I started looking at alternarives and after reading on p2p lending got fascinated with the idea and found this forum. Spent this weekend scouting the threads, but I still got a tonn of questions and unsure of what to do.
It seems that if I carefully diversify the money across many loans(100+bits) and many services(10nish) I would end up with median net gain after defaults and late payments of around 6% APR acording to the info from this forum.
I have two questions that I would be gratefull if answered: 1. Why do people invest in p2p lending with a risk and average gain (3-6% across lending platforms) when they could buy several apartments, and let the agents rent them out(as I did for 4 years now, 131 00 EUR apartment was giving me 750/month = 6.9% APR before tax) 2. What platforms would you advice me to diversify against, and which strategy to choose for each of them to minimize risk and maximise profit?
I thought it was stupid to start investing without having the homework done and asking some advice from experienced investors 8)
Thanks for all the answers that come in advance!
|
|
|
Post by mrclondon on Apr 12, 2015 20:59:13 GMT
In my case the answer to your first question is simple - I regard "buy to let" (BTL) as major hassle for uncertain returns. Remember that BTL properties will frequently need repairs, redecoration and replacement flooring after each tenant leaves, and the kitchen and bathrooms replacing every 5 to 10 years. And not forgetting capital gains tax on any capital appreciation. Unless you do all the management yourself, and have trustworthy tradesmen to handle the maintenance, the overall long run returns can be quite poor.
I do however regard property as a "good investement" so my strategy has been each time I have moved house over the last 30 years to really stretch the budget and go for the most expensive property I can afford ... a strategy which helped me when ten years ago I needed to move to inner London for my job.
In terms of choice of platforms, whilst this forum is a good place to get a feel for people's opinions of each, each platform operates slightly differently and some can be a lot more tome cinsuming than others (e.g. Funding Circle) and others only post new loans (which often fill quickly) during office hours (e.g Funding Secure, Saving Stream).
Edit: Its not clear from your post whether you are based in eurozone or the UK. For many based in the UK, euro denominated investments are simply a risk too far, as many bondora lenders have discovered to their cost over the last 6 months or so.
|
|
|
Post by zakaz on Apr 12, 2015 21:11:14 GMT
I am in Eurozone. Citizen of Estonia, currently Malta resident.
|
|
bugs4me
Member of DD Central
Posts: 1,845
Likes: 1,478
|
Post by bugs4me on Apr 12, 2015 22:06:12 GMT
I am in Eurozone. Citizen of Estonia, currently Malta resident. Firstly you would need to make sure that any UK based P2P platform would be willing to deal with a non-UK resident. I believe there are more than a couple but before taking the time to investigate the platform ask them that question first otherwise you could have wasted a great deal of time. I'm generally in agreement with mrclondon regarding BTL. The returns are fine in an appreciating market but the last time I looked closely at it the returns were in the region of 8% gross assuming a tenancy occupancy in the region of 80%. The upkeep costs are really the big unknown but you can normally factor in somewhere in the region of 2% so that nets down to 6% pre-tax. If you're in an appreciating market then this is a bonus and many London landlords rely upon this but there will be capital gains tax upon disposal assuming the property has appreciated. From my perspective, I prefer to achieve higher or equal returns elsewhere without the concerns as to whether the tenant is a good one or a not so good one.
|
|
|
Post by ranjeb on Apr 13, 2015 7:47:38 GMT
1) I don't have the money for BTL. 2) I believe housing should be to live in and not as an investment.
|
|
|
Post by zakaz on Apr 13, 2015 14:16:38 GMT
mrclondon and bugs4me Thank you for the answers, very valid points. Actually only after you mentioned it I remembered that 131 000 was an empty apartment. I did some interior design, changed the bathtub and bought the furniture. Which was around at least 10 000 EUR total(because I was in furniture business atm).
Regarding repairs and bad tenants, this shouldn't be an issue if you got the deposit and a good agreement. In an attractive and more expensive apartments you can choose the tenants(family and respectable). In cheap, microapartments repairs and furniture are dirtcheap, so even less problems there.
Opposite to the p2p lending, where the service provider might go out of service, which might end up being a loss of all the investments in there (that is still a minimum 10% loss even with diversification) and if another crisis hits there might be up to 50% defaults or late payments on loans, which is a total crisis. With real estate you at least still have the rent, even if in lesser amounts until the recovery.
Could someone proficient enough teach me their experience with p2p lending over skype or some other voip? Could compensate the wasted time. For me it seems a good idea to seek knowledge for money, then to lose much more from inexperience.
PS. Property capital gain taxes depend on the country, and are only payed when the apartment is sold. If you hold the property for renting only you don't have to worry about all that. Even renting taxes depend on the country and not your residency. For example for renting out in Croatia you pay only 10.5%
|
|
|
Post by yorkshireman on Apr 13, 2015 14:27:16 GMT
I could reinvest into the properties of another country wher renting Yields are high ATM(Chisinau, Riga) Regardless of yield, I wouldn't invest anywhere that Putin might have designs on and that includes Moldova. By the way, I clicked the “like” button in error!
|
|
jonno
Member of DD Central
nil satis nisi optimum
Posts: 2,808
Likes: 3,242
|
Post by jonno on Apr 13, 2015 14:39:02 GMT
I could reinvest into the properties of another country wher renting Yields are high ATM(Chisinau, Riga) Regardless of yield, I wouldn't invest anywhere that Putin might have designs on and that includes Moldova. By the way, I clicked the “like” button in error! Mmmm. Thought you'd had a few early Timothy Taylors. I think you can "unlike" by clicking on it again. If you like
|
|
|
Post by ablrateandy on Apr 13, 2015 15:02:33 GMT
Zakaz for a brief couple of hours before his sentiment was dashed....
|
|
|
Post by zakaz on Apr 13, 2015 15:09:41 GMT
Being Russian and living all my life in Estonia I am amazed of how people get the wrong impression from the press on the Eastern Europe politics. Russians interest in Estonia has only improved things, since like 20% of real estate in Estonia is owned, managed and run by the Russians, which is very profitable for Estonia since extra investments and taxes are always a good thing for quality of living in the country. Putin on the other side has exactly no "evil" interest in the neighboring countries, but USA stirs unrest and applies influence in the countries that border with Russia. I am an Estonian citizen, born in Estonia, raised there and know Estonian language, having one of the best friends and Estonian guy. Please get some education and real knowledge before starting big politics talks. www.valuewalk.com/2015/02/u-s-army-parade-russia-border/So the starting Cold War thing is provoked and financed by the USA to scare more loans in to the USA economy and find excuse for interfering with EU business and legalizing interrogations(on EU soil again). Russia bordering countries are not very safe for living ATM that is a fact. Moldova is not bordering with Russia and is going into EU(and adopting EUR) in the coming years, and it seems as if neither USA nor Russia has any interest there. Riga is simply very well known to me and I also have many friends there. In reality renting yields are still very high even in Ukraine so having real estate in the countries neighboring Russia is not always a bad thing. It's just that living is not very safe there. PS. yorkshireman, you can unlike the post by clicking the like button again.
|
|
|
Post by wiseclerk on Apr 13, 2015 15:37:45 GMT
Could someone proficient enough teach me their experience with p2p lending over skype or some other voip? Could compensate the wasted time. For me it seems a good idea to seek knowledge for money, then to lose much more from inexperience. There is an abundance of advice/experience online (here in the forum and on other sites/blogs). If you really want to invest 150K into p2p lending. I suggest, a) spend at least a day reading b) go about it very slowly; start with 2-3K and get to know hot it works c) then slowly top up on those platforms that you feel confident about
|
|
shimself
Member of DD Central
Posts: 2,563
Likes: 1,171
|
Post by shimself on Apr 13, 2015 16:13:50 GMT
You probably need to be lending in EUROs, you don't need currency risk. But apart from Mintos and Bondora I don't know any other Euro platforms who will lend outside their own country (if you find any tell me).
|
|
|
Post by zakaz on Apr 13, 2015 16:13:51 GMT
wiseclerk, this is great advice, but I have already spent a week reading on it and looked at the sites of all the services, also read your blog, but I got only discouraged from trying, since I see only risk and miniscule profits.
Neither your blog, nor this forum and especially not the p2p lending sites have enough info to confidently dive into it.
Ofcourse starting small might get me the info soon enough, but being taught is faster and better since 10+ year experience still beats 1-2 months of lending.
|
|
|
Post by zakaz on Apr 13, 2015 16:16:34 GMT
|
|
|
Post by yorkshireman on Apr 13, 2015 18:09:22 GMT
Being Russian and living all my life in Estonia I am amazed of how people get the wrong impression from the press on the Eastern Europe politics. Russians interest in Estonia has only improved things, since like 20% of real estate in Estonia is owned, managed and run by the Russians, which is very profitable for Estonia since extra investments and taxes are always a good thing for quality of living in the country. Putin on the other side has exactly no "evil" interest in the neighboring countries, but USA stirs unrest and applies influence in the countries that border with Russia. I am an Estonian citizen, born in Estonia, raised there and know Estonian language, having one of the best friends and Estonian guy. Please get some education and real knowledge before starting big politics talks. www.valuewalk.com/2015/02/u-s-army-parade-russia-border/So the starting Cold War thing is provoked and financed by the USA to scare more loans in to the USA economy and find excuse for interfering with EU business and legalizing interrogations(on EU soil again). Russia bordering countries are not very safe for living ATM that is a fact. Moldova is not bordering with Russia and is going into EU(and adopting EUR) in the coming years, and it seems as if neither USA nor Russia has any interest there. Riga is simply very well known to me and I also have many friends there. In reality renting yields are still very high even in Ukraine so having real estate in the countries neighboring Russia is not always a bad thing. It's just that living is not very safe there. PS. yorkshireman, you can unlike the post by clicking the like button again. I’m reasonably acquainted with Russia and it’s people, consequently I feel that you may be looking at this issue just from the Russian point of view, in which case may I respectfully suggest that you read the following: www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/europe/estonia/11530064/Sitting-near-a-nuclear-tripwire-Estonias-president-urges-Nato-to-send-troops-to-defend-his-country.htmlBy the way, I wouldn’t be so mean as to unlike the post!
|
|